Sister My Sister Bake Shop Review: Big Bear’s Bakery for Fresh Cupcakes, Cookies, and Custom Cakes

Sister My Sister Bake Shop in Big Bear is a local favorite for fresh cupcakes, cookies, and custom cakes made daily on-site. 

This charming mountain bakery combines small-town warmth with big flavor, offering everything from espresso drinks to beautifully crafted pastries. Step inside, and you’re greeted by the sweet aroma of homemade treats that make it worth finding. 

It’s also one of the few true bakeries in Big Bear that bakes fresh in-house each morning, setting it apart from the coffee shops and supermarket counters around town.

• Address: 40191 Big Bear Blvd, Big Bear Lake, CA 92315
• Phone: 909-878-0878

Ambience

First Impression

Sister My Sister Bake Shop is a bit of a hidden gem—literally. The first thing you notice is how easy it is to miss; the storefront sits quietly off the road, and the main sign is partly obscured by a large bush. 

Even the sign by the front door is darkened, making it blend into the background. Once you spot it, though, there’s a sense of discovery—like finding a secret bakery only locals know about.

The bakery is at 40191 Big Bear Blvd, Big Bear Lake, CA. Phone number is 909-878-0878.

Decor

Inside, the décor is simple yet perfectly suited for a cozy mountain bakery. You’ll find charming display cases filled with fresh pastries and cakes, a touch of rustic charm in the finishes, and warm tones that make the baked goods pop visually. 

It’s not overdone or flashy—just that comforting, homespun vibe that fits right in with Big Bear’s relaxed mountain atmosphere.

Comfort

The space itself is modest but well-designed for what it is. There’s enough room for a handful of customers to browse the pastry cases comfortably without feeling cramped. 

It’s not a large sit-down café, and there’s no seating to enjoy your coffee or latte inside. Unlike spots such as Copper Q or Moonridge Coffee, Sister My Sister is designed for grab-and-go convenience.

This is perfect if you want to take your drink for a stroll through the Village or up to the lake. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee or selecting a box of treats to go, it feels just right—cozy, efficient, and inviting enough to linger for a moment while the smell of fresh-baked goods fills the air.

Service

Staff Friendliness

The service at Sister My Sister Bake Shop feels genuinely warm and personal. As soon as I stepped inside, a staff member appeared from the back within seconds to greet me—no awkward waiting around. 

She was patient as I took my time scanning every pastry and cupcake, never rushing me even though I was clearly indecisive. Her friendly demeanor set the tone for a pleasant visit, making me feel welcome and unhurried.

Efficiency

Even with the cozy size of the shop and a steady flow of customers, the service runs smoothly. Orders are taken quickly, payments are processed without delay, and everything moves at an easy but organized pace. 

It’s the kind of efficient, small-town operation where you can tell they’ve perfected their routine—balancing attentiveness with speed so no one feels overlooked.

Knowledge

The staff’s knowledge of their products really stands out. She confidently described each cupcake flavor, from the classics to the more creative seasonal options, and was careful to point out which pastries contained nuts—a big plus for anyone with allergies. 

That level of attention and product familiarity shows pride in their craft and genuine care for their customers.

Food

Variety

Sister My Sister Bake Shop offers an impressive assortment of sweet treats that instantly catch your eye the moment you step in. The glass display cases are filled with cupcakes, pies, cookies, scones, and rich, chocolatey brownies—all baked fresh and beautifully presented. 

They even offer a few gluten-free options, which is a thoughtful touch for visitors with dietary restrictions. While most come for the sweets, they also bake savory pastries such as jalapeño cheese croissants for those who prefer something less sugary. 

Whether you’re in the mood for something light and buttery or rich and indulgent, there’s a little bit of everything to satisfy any craving. buttery or rich and indulgent, there’s a little bit of everything to satisfy any craving.

Custom Orders

Beyond their daily selection, the bakery also creates custom-decorated cakes for birthdays, weddings, and special occasions. These are made to order with care and creativity, not pre-made designs. 

Just make sure to plan ahead—custom cakes must be pre-ordered in advance so the team can perfect every detail.

Freshness and Flavor

Every pastry and cupcake at Sister My Sister Bake Shop tastes like it was baked that very morning. The textures are spot on—flaky scones, chewy cookies, and soft, tender cupcakes that stay moist without being heavy. 

Each bite feels homemade, balanced, and never overly sweet or artificial. It’s clear that the bakers care about both quality and consistency, giving every item that fresh-from-the-oven comfort you can only get from a true small-batch bakery.

Cupcakes

I tried four cupcake flavors—tiramisu, chocolate, vanilla, and lemon—and each one was a pleasant surprise. All were wonderfully moist, with that just-baked freshness that tells you they weren’t sitting in a case for long. 

The tiramisu cupcake had a light espresso flavor with creamy frosting that wasn’t too sweet, echoing the richness of the classic Italian dessert. The chocolate cupcake was deep and fudgy, satisfying without being heavy. The vanilla was soft and buttery with a nostalgic, homemade taste, while the lemon stood out for its bright, tangy flavor that balanced sweetness with citrus zest. 

Each cupcake felt thoughtfully made—consistent in texture, generous in frosting, and clearly crafted with quality ingredients.

Value for the Money

Pricing

Regular-sized cupcakes are priced at $4 each, but if you buy four, you’ll save 25¢ per cupcake—a nice little bonus for those wanting to sample multiple flavors. Of course, prices can always change, but for a handcrafted treat in a locally owned bakery, it feels fair and in line with what you’d expect for quality baked goods in Big Bear.

Portion Size

Each cupcake is a standard, filling portion—not oversized, but generous enough to satisfy a sweet craving. The cake itself is moist and dense without feeling heavy, and the frosting layer on top is thick and creamy, providing the perfect balance between texture and sweetness. You get the sense that every bite is meant to be enjoyed, not rushed.

Overall Value

Considering the craftsmanship, freshness, and local charm of Sister My Sister Bake Shop, the pricing feels justified. 

This isn’t your average grocery store bakery—it’s a specialty bake shop where each cupcake, scone, or cookie is made with care. You’re paying a little more, but you’re getting small-batch quality and the experience of supporting a beloved local business in the heart of Big Bear.

Overall Experience

Highlights

Sister My Sister Bake Shop stands out as a boutique bakery with big flavor. From moist, delicious cupcakes to flaky pastries and rich brownies, every item feels handcrafted with care. 

The variety is impressive for a small mountain bakery, offering something for everyone—whether you’re after a morning scone, a mid-day coffee, or a beautifully decorated cake for a special occasion.

Room for Improvement

If there’s one area that could use attention, it’s the exterior signage. The front sign is partially hidden by a bush, and the smaller sign by the door is dark and easy to miss. A more visible, well-lit sign would make it easier for first-time visitors to find this hidden gem without driving past it.

Final Thoughts

Sister My Sister Bake Shop is a must-stop for anyone who loves freshly baked goods made with passion and personality. The shop’s interior can get a little warm on busy days, so it’s often best to grab your treats to go and enjoy them outdoors in the mountain air. 

Be sure to arrive early. The best pastries and cupcakes tend to sell out fast, and once you’ve found it, you’ll understand why locals consider it one of Big Bear’s sweetest spots.